Overall: 2.2 / 5 based on 4 reviews
1 of 4 reviewers would recommend this product to a friend.
I like this shirt -
By: giantbeagle from Canandaigua, NY
Top 1000 Contributor
Before buying this shirt I read the reviews here. They were not stellar. One said the shoulders were too wide and sleeves too short. Another said the shirt was too wide and too long. Put that all together and you have a shirt that fits me perfectly. Another review had bad stitching on his shirt, so I studied mine carefully. The only issue I saw was that one side of the size tag on the collar was sewn on with much more thread than the other. It's hidden behind the collar anyway so no big deal. I like the fit of the shirt and the softness of the twill. It's first job is to be my couch shirt; worn when it's chilly in the house, which is pretty much from now until April.
Montana Morning Plaid -
By: therealmccoy from San Francisco, CA
The plaid shirt looked great online. A rugged, but utility shirt. On arrival, the shirt felt like an XXL when I tried on the Medium I ordered. The shirt went to the bottom of my jean fly. The material was also not as durable as I imagined. A bit disappointing for Orvis quality.
An Orvis Embarrassment -
By: smarty2 from Victoria, BC
Upon receiving this shirt, I tried it on immediately. The fit was just barely acceptable- very broad shoulders an short sleeves, giving the overall length required but a cheap looking fit. I then noticed that the stitching on one pocket was broken and hanging loose, ready to unravel further. Upon further examination, I noticed poor stitching examples elsewhere on the garment. The fabric is also thin. I must return this right away as it is basically garbage. I also resent having to pay return postage for a defective item. I will strongly consider not purchasing from Orvis in the future, as I can get cheap junk at high prices locally.
Response from: Orvis Customer Service Team
Posted: 3/7/2013 1:25:28 PM
Orvis contacted this customer and thanked him for his honest feedback. We are sorry to hear that the Montana Morning Plaid Shirt didn't fit as expected. We let our customer know our customer service agents would be happy to go over specific measurements for any of our garments before he places an order. And, of course, Orvis will happily exchange or refund any item; we want our customers to be happy with all of their Orvis purchases.
Too wide -
By: Winstonriver from Carolina
This shirt almost has all the great qualities of Orvis except the shirt comes exceptionally wide and "blousy." For that I am returning it. Otherwise a great product.